Your employer cannot deduct wages without your written consent — illegal under BCEA Section 34. Here's what to demand in writing and how to refer the matter to the CCMA.
FreeSouth African Law5 related guides
Direct Answer
An employer may only deduct from your salary with your written agreement or if authorised by law (e.g., PAYE, UIF) or a court order. Deductions for alleged damages, losses, or "company property" without your written consent are unlawful under Section 34 of the BCEA. You can demand repayment and refer to the CCMA.
The law above is general — your case may be different
Describe exactly what happened and get a specific answer based on your facts. 2 free answers, no account needed.
“An employer may not make any deduction from an employee's remuneration unless — (a) the employee agrees in writing; or (b) the deduction is made in terms of a law, collective agreement, court order or arbitration award.”
What to Do
Step-by-Step Guide
1Request an itemised payslip for the month the deduction was made. You are legally entitled to one under Section 33 of the BCEA.
2Write to your employer noting that the deduction was made without your written consent in violation of Section 34 of the BCEA, and demand repayment within 7 days.
3If your employer refuses, refer a dispute to the CCMA (wages/remuneration dispute) within 30 days of the refusal.
4You may also lodge a complaint with the Department of Labour, which can conduct a labour inspection and direct the employer to repay the amount.
What to Say
Exact Words to Use
“"The deduction of R[X] from my [month] salary was made without my written consent and is unlawful under Section 34 of the Basic Conditions of Employment Act. I require this amount to be repaid in my next salary payment. If not, I will refer the matter to the CCMA."”
Tone: In writing to employer/HR/payroll
Now practise saying it. The Advocate has a scenario that walks you through exactly this situation — phrase by phrase, with audio playback and a practice drill. Free to try.
Can my employer deduct money because I broke company equipment?
Only if you signed a written agreement allowing such deductions before the incident, and even then, the deduction must be fair and proportionate. A blanket policy in an employment contract allowing deductions for any damage may be enforceable, but deductions for losses you did not cause or that result from normal work wear are not lawful.
Can a garnishee order take money from my salary?
Yes — a garnishee order (emoluments attachment order) is a court order that authorises deductions from your salary to repay a debt. However, the order must have been granted by a court in your jurisdiction and you must have been properly served. Many garnishee orders in South Africa are fraudulently or improperly obtained — consult Legal Aid if you did not know about the debt or court proceedings.
An illegal deduction is money that belongs to you. This scenario trains you to challenge it formally — with the exact legal basis, the words to use, and how to respond when your employer claims the deduction was justified. Free to try.